Best Mattresses with a Long Lifespan

As a shopper, you surely want to buy only the best that your money could afford – more importantly for big purchases like mattresses. There are many factors that affect our decision, including the price, mattress features, and even the brand name. Most of us take a look at the price, but we also have our own perspective as to what makes a mattress a good value for our money. One of the things that we have to look into is the durability of the mattress.

Mattress Durability Definition

Just like with other things that we buy, we always think about how long they will last. Mattresses are meant to last for years, but there are some that have a short lifespan mainly because they are not that durable. Additionally, there are many of us who don’t know how to properly care for our mattress. While most new mattresses don’t really need too much attention from you, they still require that you don’t do anything that could cause damage, such as spills that can be very hard to clean sometimes.

The lifespan of the mattress refers to how long it remains useful in which it should be able to maintain most of its support and comfort. If the mattress is durable, it can last for years. For most products, they are expected to last anywhere from seven to 10 years. Others can last for more, provided that proper care is given to the mattress.

Are Expensive Mattresses More Durable than Affordable Ones?

Mattresses vary greatly, particularly on how long they will survive. It is typical for a mattress to wear out just like your other belongings. It will definitely become unpleasant because the comfort layer/s eventually lose their ability to give the sleeper his or her desired comfort level. When the mattress no longer feels comfortable when you first bought it, it’s one of the biggest signs that tell you it’s time to buy a new mattress.

As you do your research and go shopping, you will find how some mattresses vary greatly in price. What’s surprising is that some are almost identical in features and construction and yet one is affordable, while the other is worth thousands. One reason for this is because of the brand name. There are many other reasons that increase the pricing of the mattress, but does this really mean an expensive mattress is much better than affordable ones?

The truth is that the price shouldn’t be the first thing consumers should look at. Materials, construction, and other aspects play an important role in determining how long a mattress will last.

How to Know How Long Your New Mattress will Last

One of the first things you should consider if you’re concerned about the longevity of your new mattress is to look at how it is made. If the mattress is well-constructed, it will be sturdy and you will notice that it recovers the next day after you have slept on it. No matter what type of mattress it is, the filling and the other materials used should remain in place and wouldn’t look squashed. As for the cover or the ticking, it should have good quality, which will be effective in preventing stains. Some covers are very thin and may be prone to ripping. This doesn’t mean though that thin covers should be avoided as they can actually improve the airflow of the mattress. A good quality cover will not easily be ripped and can be stretched without problems.

The mattress when you use it will compress and bend, particularly the upper layers, which will deflect more than the bottom layers of the mattress. This is partly because the upper layers have softer materials than those that are deeper into the mattress. Additionally, the upper layers are where we sleep, so they are closer to the sleep surface, which subjects them to direct contact with the sleeper. This means they absorb the forces of compression more than the deeper layers. Due to the constant contact, the components and the materials used will change over time. Note though that the firmness or softness of the mattress has a role to play here as well as thickness and the quality of the materials used.

There are many materials used in mattresses that are less durable than others, so they become softer over time as they continue to break down. Meanwhile, the fiber materials will become firmer, less plush, and will eventually compress after years of use. This is why it is important to determine the upper layers of the mattress, namely the transition and the comfort layers, which will be useful in assessing how long your new mattress will last. This is because these layers are the weakest in terms of durability, while the support core of the mattress is definitely the strongest part.

There are other factors that will also affect the lifespan of the mattress, including:

Body type of the sleeper: The higher the body mass index (BMI) of a person, the deeper the compression of layers will be compared to lighter people. It is therefore important to go for a firmer and more durable mattress if you’re on the heavier side.

Preferences and sensitivities: There are some people who want a softer mattress and there are also some who are quite sensitive to the changes that may have happened. Those who are extra sensitive may need to quickly replace their mattress since they may no longer sleep well.

Edge support: There are some mattresses that have excellent support at the edges, but there are also some that are too soft around the edges. This can lead to reduced lifespan, particularly if the mattress is already soft.

There is no specific way to predict or quantify how long a certain mattress will last. One reason is that there are so many variables and unknowns, which make the process complex. It is important, however, to confirm that the mattress meets the quality or durability minimum specifications, you can reasonably expect that your mattress will have a useful lifetime of seven to 10 years.

Which Mattress Type Lasts the Longest?

Like all products that we possess, mattresses also have a useful life expectancy and therefore should be replaced periodically after this is done. Unfortunately for us consumers, there are hundreds of mattresses and brands, so comparing them one by one can be such a monumental task. Variances do exist, but you can look at the main types of mattresses to compare which will last longer.

Below you will find the most common types of mattresses, along with information related to their durability.

Mattress Type Average Lifespan % of Durability Complaints Customer Satisfaction Rating
Coil Mattresses (e.g. pocket coil, offset coil, and continuous coil) 5 to 7 years 20% to 30% 68% to 74%
Natural Latex 12 years Less than 5% 86%
Blended Latex 10 years 8% 75%
Latex over Foam 8 years 10& 80%
High Density (HD) Memory Foam 10 years 7% 80%
Other Memory Foams (Medium Density to Low Density) 5 to 8 years 10% to 20% 80% to 81%
Waterbeds 10 years 8& 80%

What the Table Above Tells Us

Based on the table above, you can say that latex mattresses are the type of mattress that can last the longest. The average lifespan is eight to 12 years depending on the type of latex. If you’re really worried about the durability of your latex mattress, it is safe to choose natural latex instead of blended and latex over foam subtypes. Pure latex foam is considered the most durable material in mattresses because it is resilient and can therefore resist impressions as well as degradation. Latex can be processed through Talalay or Dunlop. The main differences between the two procedures are that Dunlop provides more support, so it is a bit firmer and Talalay produces a more yielding mattress and is definitely more expensive than Dunlop.

The second to the longest lifespan is memory foam mattress. Just like with latex, the blend of materials as well as the construction will play a part in determining whether the mattress will last long or not. HD foams are more durable than medium and lower density ones because they have a much denser or thicker material, which makes them more resilient against impressions over time. HD foams can have a density of more than five pounds. The core of the foam mattresses is also important in determining their lifespan. Cores that are over 2.5 pounds are more resilient, while those with less than two pounds tend to become softer and with less support in a much shorter amount of time.

Mattresses with High Durability Scores

While latex mattresses are ranked with the highest durability score, it doesn’t mean that all latex mattresses are resilient. It still depends on the construction, materials used, and other factors to determine the length of life of a certain mattress. In fact, you will see below that it is not a latex mattress that grabs the top spot.

1. Amerisleep Liberty

This may come as a surprise to many people, particularly those who are eyeing on latex mattresses. Amerisleep Liberty is actually a memory foam mattress, which is the type of mattress ranked second in the durability comparison table above. Nevertheless, Amerisleep Liberty has received several compliments and great reviews from its owners. Even after many years of use, this mattress still retains its shape, support, and comfort – making it easy for the Liberty to be the top choice for durability.

What Makes Amerisleep Liberty Durable?

The secret to a long lifespan of the Liberty mattress by Amerisleep is in its construction. The 12 inch profile consists of three separate layers made of high quality foam:

Three inches of Bio-Pur memory foam: This is the top layer that provides cooling and comfort for the sleeper, while making sure that pressure points disappear. Bio-Pur is a sturdy type of foam that works by pulling heat away from the body, so that it is easier to maintain a cooler sleeping surface. This prevents the sleeper from waking up at night drenched in sweat. As you may know, sweat can contribute to foam and mattress damage.

Two inches of transition foam: For the second layer, this is where the sleeper gets the support from the mattress and it is also where most of the pressure points are relieved. It is very supportive base foam to provide backing for the top layer, which may be sturdy, but is also a lot softer than the middle layer.

Seven inches of Bio-Core foam: As for the bottom layer, this is where deep compression support is provided for the sleeper. It is also where the mattress as a whole gets the support it needs to handle the weight and the compression from the other two layers.

As for the cover of the mattress, it is thin, but is well-constructed. The materials used are Celliant, polyester, and spandex. The cover improves the airflow of the mattress, but at the same time it is elastic and even promotes sleep.

Amerisleep Liberty is a medium feel mattress, so when you lie down on it, you will feel the noticeable sinkage. However, it will not give you that stuck feeling that most people get when they have a very soft mattress. It is still supportive and you can expect to feel that kind of support to last for years. What’s more, Amerisleep Liberty offers a trial period of 100 days. If you’re not satisfied with it, you can easily ask for a refund when you return the mattress. The warranty covers 20 years of ownership with the first 10 years free for repairs or replacement.

2. Saatva Mattress

The second in the list of our durable mattresses is the Saatva mattress. The company sells online exclusively, but that doesn’t mean you can’t test the mattress as to whether or not it is the right one for you. Saatva offers a premium mattress that provides the advantages of both foam and innerspring mattresses. This hybrid mattress uses cutting edge technology that allows it to not only give you a restful sleep, but also a durable mattress.

Saatva mattresses are based on coil on coil construction, which means there are two sets of coils that have been individually wrapped. The first set is for responding to the body as well as in contouring to its shape, while the second one consists of tempered steel coils that are effective in preventing sagging.

What Makes the Saatva Mattress Durable?

Just like with Amerisleep Liberty, the Saatva mattress is durable, thanks to the way it is constructed. Here are the details:

Two inches of euro-style pillow top: Encased in a cover that uses organic cotton, the purpose of the pillow top is to provide a plush feel for the sleeper, while making sure he or she stays comfortable and cool all night.

One inch of laminated memory foam: This thin memory foam layer is aimed at providing pressure relief for the sleeper. It targets the lower back to help it avoid stress and tension.

Individually wrapped coils: The coils are between foam casings to add more comfort for the sleeper. Aside from that, they add more sleep surface and improve the durability of the mattress.

Tempered steel coils: Just below the foam casing, the mattress contains the tempered steel coils, which have been designed to provide better support for the mattress as a whole. These coils are also used to bolster the anti-sag structure of the mattress.

According to Saatva, their mattresses can last for 12 to 15 years – which is almost twice as long as their competitors. It is recommended though that you rotate the mattress once every six months after it has been delivered and then rotate it once yearly.

3. Helix Sleep

For those who can’t find something that meets their requirements, perhaps a custom-made mattress is the solution. This is what the Helix mattress is about. It is fully customizable, so that sleepers can enjoy the ultimate comfort. To get a full customized mattress, you will only need to fill out a questionnaire on their website. One great thing about the mattress is that you can specify what you want for both sides, which is definitely useful for those who share the bed with their partners.

What Makes The Helix Mattress Durable?

Helix is made of foam mattress, but not the typical one, since it is made based on the detailed requirements of the sleeper. Although it is customized, all the mattresses come with the following specifications:

10-inch profile: The mattress consists of four different layers that consist of materials, including their Helix Dynamic Foam, polyfoam, and microcoils.

First layer: This layer is designed for cooling, bounce, and responsiveness. It measures two inches and uses Helix Dynamic Foam.

Second layer: As for the second layer, it consists of 2.4 inches of microcoils for pressure relief, softness, and more bounce.

Third layer: This is the comfort foam layer with two inches of quality polyfoam for even better comfort for the sleeper. It also provides deep compression support.

Fourth layer: Finally, this layer measures four inches of polyfoam to function as the foundation of the other layers above it.

The cover is entirely made of polyester. It is soft to the touch, but it is sturdy enough to withstand stretching. Helix mattress is somewhat new in the mattress world, but it uses high-grade materials to ensure that it will last longer than most of its competition. The company has not provided an estimate about how long the mattress will last, but with proper care, it should last for seven years at least. Unfortunately, the warranty is fairly short with only 10 years of limited warranty. It is pretty standard as it only covers the defects of the mattress and not those that arise from misuse.

If you’re not happy with the mattress though, you can get a full refund if you return it within 100 days. Note that the refund includes shipping, which makes the process less expensive than other mattresses’ return policies.

4. Stearns and Foster

Stearns and Foster is one of the established brands in the mattress market. In fact, it has been around for more than 170 years. Its presence along makes it safe to say that they are among the trusted brands around. It is a luxury brand that uses deluxe materials and the mattresses are expected to have an advanced design. The first time owners lie down on the mattress is said to be an experience that ranges from good to excellent.

You have plenty of choices when it comes to Stearns and Foster mattresses. They have luxury mattresses that feature regular foam, gel foam, latex, and microcoils among many others. There have been some complaints about the durability of the mattresses though, which is why the company changed some of their materials to improve the longevity and durability of their products. Thick models with pillow tops tend to have the lowest rating in satisfaction, so it is best to avoid them to lessen your worries about durability.

There are a number of Stearns and Foster mattresses, but we will talk about the Lux Estate Hybrid Collection, which is a new line from the company. It is a hybrid mattress that provides the advantages of both spring and foam mattresses.

What Makes This Stearns and Foster Mattress Durable?

 Stearns and Foster already introduced the Lux Estate Collection and basically, the Lux Estate Hybrid Collection is the same except for the enhanced features.  Here are the features you can expect from the mattress that make it quite durable:

Quilt: Made with PrimaComfort Ultra Stretch that’s exclusive to Stearns and Foster, the cover fabric is infused with cashmere and silk. The cover is stretchy, smooth, and strong. It is also hand-tufted to ensure that the layers below it remain stabilized. Because it is tufted, it means that you will have the same feeling with the mattress for some time because it helps pre-compress the foams underneath.

Comfort layers: There are foam layers in this collection featuring mainly gel memory foam and phase change materials. The latter means that they change their state physically to ensure that temperature remains at the designated range. Meanwhile, the gel memory foam acts as a heat sink to pull away heat from the body of the sleeper.

Edge system: Stearns and Foster uses their own technology known as StabiLux Edge System that encases the comfort layers as well as the microcoils in the mattresses. There is a perimeter rod that improves the support for the top layers, while ensuring that the sleep surface is completely usable, including the edges. Plus, this particular technology maintains the coil array, so that it will not move out of its place.

Support: There are dual pocket coils in the mattress for a firm response, while making sure there is gentle cushioning for the body of the sleeper. This means the mattresses are suitable for both lightweight and heavyweight users.

Stearns and Foster mattresses have good support, which most of the users praise. Edge support is especially sturdy, so you can sleep and sit near the edge without worrying about slipping. Additionally, the mattresses are easy to maintain because they don’t need flipping. You will need to rotate them regularly though, which will help reduce weal and sagging. Unfortunately, the mattresses are very heavy with some that weigh from 65 to 180 pounds, so rotating them on your own can be such a huge problem. The good news is that there are grips on the sides to help you position the mattresses. As for the warranty, the mattresses are covered by a 10-year warranty that is a full non-prorated coverage.

5. Sealy

Another recognizable name in the mattress world is Sealy. There are also plenty of choices for mattresses, so you could find what’s best for you. The mattresses can be a little expensive though with some that start at $2000, but you can also search for Sealy products that are in the hundreds. Since they have a wide range of products, you can find different coils in the form of offset, open, and pocket coils. They also have gel memory foam mattresses.

Sealy Posturepedic mattresses are among their popular lines of mattresses. Just like their other lines, Posturepedic is reported to have fair to better durability, particularly for those who occasionally or temporarily use their mattress.

How Durable are Sealy Posturepedic Mattresses?

There are at least 22% of owners of Posturepedic, particularly those who have pillow top models, who reported that there are body impressions and sagging within the first three years of ownership. However, many owners also say that their Sealy mattresses can last for at least six years when used regularly.

The good news is that Posturepedic is made for people who experience back pain. This mattress line aims to reduce pain, including at the hip, shoulder and lower back. Many owners compliment the line for providing good comfort and minimizing pressure points. The mattress ages and sags after about six years without proper care though, so there are some consumers who report pain as well.

You can avoid durability problems with Posturepedic mattresses by going for those with high density polyfoam. These mattresses last longer, so stay away from those that have thick layers of LD foam. Warranty lasts for 10 years and also covers sagging of the mattress. When making a claim though, make sure the indentation depth is at least 1.5 inches.

How to Take Care of Your Mattress

No matter how durable the mattress is if you are a very careless owner, it will not last long. As the owner, you have the responsibility to take care of it, so that you can help extend its life. Here are some ways to add more years to the lifespan of your mattress:

1. Read the instructions from the manufacturer. Once you have bought and received your new mattress, it will come with a set of care instructions as advised by the manufacturer. Ensure that you read and understand them completely before you put them somewhere else. When keeping the instructions, hide them in a place that you can remember in case you need to read them again later.

2. Check if the mattress needs flipping. Some mattresses, particularly memory foam mattresses, don’t need flipping or turning. You only need to rotate them, so that they the compressions will be equal all over the mattress. If, however, your new mattress needs to be turned, learn about how often and how it should be turned properly. There are mattresses that require turning from one side to another, while others require switching the foot and head ends.

3. Know how to clean the mattress. Cleaning instructions will mostly be provided by the manufacturer. If your mattress is tufted, you will need to exert extra effort in caring for it, especially when vacuuming it. When washing the outer fabric, it is best to use a very mild detergent.

4. Know when to remove the cover. If you will not use your mattress, such as when you go on a vacation, you should strip it to help air it out. You should always let your mattress breathe, especially when you detect that there is a slight odor. You can simply leave both the foundation and the mattress uncovered for a few hours. Expose them in a well-ventilated area and this will help get rid of the unpleasant scent.

5. Use pads for protection. There are protective pads that you can purchase. When you buy one, go for a pad that is of good quality and is washable. This will help keep the mattress set fresh and stain-free. You can also use protective pads for your foundation if you want.

6. Don’t ever dry clean the mattress. When dry cleaning, you will need to use chemicals in order for the process to be effective. Unfortunately, these dry cleaning agents can harm the fabric as well as the other materials in the mattress. The only recommended method of cleaning for a mattress is through vacuuming. If there is a stubborn stain, use cold water with mild soap and apply the mixture very lightly. Avoid soaking the mattress and even your foundation.

A good quality mattress doesn’t really need a lot of attention from your part. It does help to give it a little bit of care to ensure that it will last for years. It also helps if you choose from the list of mattresses above since they are the ones that have been rated high for their durability and lifespan.