List of the Most Trusted Mattress Brands

There are so many mattress brands that sleepers can choose from these days. On the one hand, these options allow the consumers to have many choices to select from so they can see what’s the most suitable for them. On the other hand, it is quite confusing and there are some brands or products that can be deceiving. Plus, there are many types of mattresses around as well, from innerspring to memory foam to latex and then some more.

Currently, there isn’t a leader in mattresses, but there are brands that are recognized because consumers trust them. From how they treat the sleepers to the mattresses they offer to the warranties they provide, these mattress brands have established their reputation to make sure their customers are satisfied for the long term.

What Makes a Top Mattress Brand?

There are new brands and there are ones that have been around for years. The established brands that have been around for at least 10 years still exist for a reason – and one is because customers trust them. This is not to say, however, that the new brands aren’t trustworthy. Both the old and new brands share some qualities that make the sleepers have confidence in them and these include:

They produce top quality mattresses. These companies aim to make the sleepers happy by providing mattresses that use quality materials without putting a dent on the customer’s budget.

They have high ratings based on reviews and customer testimonials. When you search for mattresses to buy, one of the first things you do is to read reviews from other customers. You’re not alone with this practice because people tend to trust other people. A survey showed that 39% of users read online reviews before they buy anything, while another 49% would occasionally include online ratings as part of the shopping process. All in all, that’s 88% of consumers, so it is easy to conclude that testimonials and reviews do help win the trust of many people. This is why the trusted brands include these reviews from their past customers in their websites, ads, or social media feeds.

They are honest. In real life, transparency and honesty are among the top qualities that make us trust other people – and that’s the same with mattress brands. It is easy to claim that the product is excellent and uses top materials, but then some customers complain about the quality and the durability of the mattress. If this happens, customers can lose their trust on the brand. People tend to respect companies that are honest and direct with them.

They are accountable. Many online and even offline mattress companies offer a money back guarantee, along with a free trial. Such tactic does increase conversion rates, but what really matters is the company gets the job done. Brands should exhibit a degree of accountability to gain trust from the users. They should be able to deliver what they are promising whether it is about free shipping, guarantees, or trial offers.

Being trustworthy is indeed a valuable asset for a mattress brand. With the tough competition these days, it is important that brands meet the expectations of the consumers.

Some Facts about Mattresses and Brands

The past couple of years showed that the two most popular types of mattress are innerspring and memory foam mattresses. But the latter has received a much higher ratings from the owners. About 80% of the mattress owners are happy with the product that they have bought and such satisfaction is high for memory foam mattresses that are less than $1800. This shows that you don’t have to shell out more money to be happy with your purchase unlike with other types, such as latex and air mattresses whose satisfaction is parallel to the amount of money you spend. In other words, the more expensive those mattresses are, the more satisfied you will be.

Similarly, the price doesn’t dictate the quality of the mattress. There are actually quite a number of mattress models that are rated high by the customers even though they are just $1000 and below. In addition, there are more expensive options, including those that are over $2500, have the same ratings as some lower priced mattresses.

For years, buying a mattress meant going to a showroom and checking out the products. Online shopping has changed, evolved, and is even starting to dominate the mattress world. Buying online is now more common than ever and more and more customers choose to make a purchase at the comforts of their home with their devices instead of visiting physical mattress stores.

Top Mattress Brands

The main question now is this: what are the most trusted mattress brands these days? Since choosing the right mattress is really an aggravating mission, we’ve taken the liberty to list the best brands that many sleepers trust when it comes to quality, comfort, lifespan, and features such as motion transfer and heat retention. Without further ado, here they are:

1. Amerisleep

Amerisleep offers five mattress models.

The mattresses use bio-friendly foams.

The mattresses are rated high when it comes to support.

Amerisleep mattresses remain cool and dry no matter how warm the temperature is.

Who is the Amerisleep mattress for?
Amerisleep has different comfort levels for their mattress models, so there are many choices for sleepers.

The mattresses are great for eco-minded buyers.

The mattresses are inexpensive, but come with high quality materials and advanced technology.

Who wouldn’t like Amerisleep?
For those who are used to innerspring mattresses, Amerisleep may not be suitable for them.

Those who aren’t comfortable with memory foam mattresses wouldn’t like Amerisleep mattresses.

Amerisleep takes the top spot when it comes to trust. Upon searching for Amerisleep reviews online, you will mostly find positive reactions and feedback from their customers no matter what mattress they buy. From the quality of the materials used to the process of manufacturing the mattresses, Amerisleep pleases not only the average consumers, but also those who are very picky, including those who only want eco-friendly products.

The company has been around for several years with a reputation for offering high quality mattresses without going outside the budget of the customers. Amerisleep targets all kinds of sleepers, including those who are searching for an eco-friendly memory foam mattress. They have mattresses that are firm, soft, or something in between, making them a great choice for everyone.

Unlike those other existing mattress-in-a-box companies, Amerisleep doesn’t limit the choice of mattress to simply one comfort level. There are five available mattresses from the company and they range from soft to firm. Here’s an overview of their mattresses:

– For a softer mattress experience, the best choices are Independence and Colonial models.

– If you’re looking for a medium feel mattress, the Liberty is the recommended model.

– For those who want a firm mattress, the Revere and the Americana are the ideal options.

Amerisleep uses memory foams that are not only eco-friendly, but also use advanced technologies to ensure that sleepers remain comfortable and undisturbed throughout the night. They also come in really reasonable prices and with an exceptional 20-year warranty, which applies to all models. It is not just because of these qualities why many customers trust the brand; but it’s also due to the fact that Amerisleep is among the oldest companies that offer mattress-in-a-box.

The company was founded in 2007 and since then, it has set itself apart from the rest of the mattress-in-a-box companies as well as the popular ones. They have achieved this through providing high quality mattresses, reliable customer service, and innovative features. Amerisleep is headquartered in Scottsdale, Arizona and ships the mattresses to buyers who live in the United States and Canada.

Socially Responsible

Amerisleep takes a step further when it comes to being socially responsible, especially when it comes to the environment. During the course of its production chain, Amerisleep sticks to practices that don’t impact the environment. They use a formula that’s plant-based and throughout the manufacturing process, they don’t emit anything harmful to the surroundings. Plus, when they deliver the mattresses, they pack them in an eco-box.

Purchase Process

Amerisleep keeps the prices of their mattresses low as they have adopted online purchasing. Although there are no brick and mortar stores where the mattresses are available for testing, you can buy the products at as well as on When you buy, shipping costs aren’t a problem if you’re in the US, except if you’re in Alaska or Hawaii. International orders also have shipping fees. The mattress will be delivered to your doorstep, will be rolled in a thin plastic tube, and will be compressed. It’s easy to unpack the mattress, which the plastic wrap will only have to be cut lengthwise.

2. Serta iComfort

There are a total of three iComfort lines with 15 models.

The mattresses use gel beads that are infused within the memory foam.

The iComfort lines were introduced in 2011, but were revamped in 2014 and there are now new models with new specs and features.

Who is the iComfort line for?
The mattress line is for people who are looking for memory foam mattresses.

The iComfort is also for those who want an alternative to Tempurpedic models.

Who should avoid iComfort?
If you’re not a fan of memory foam, Serta iComfort may not be a good choice.

If you’re looking for a more affordable mattress, this isn’t recommended for you.

You want a mattress that can last for over three years.

Serta has been around since 1933 with their headquarters located in Illinois. It is currently one of the largest mattress brands in the US, especially when it comes to innersprings. The iComfort line though consists of memory foam mattresses that offer cooling comfort, which is one of the biggest complaints about this type of mattress. This is why those want to switch to memory foam usually look for a mattress that has premium cooling features.

The iComfort was introduced back in 2011 mainly due to the success of memory foam mattresses. What sets iComfort apart from its competition is its use of gel infused foam. This kind of foam uses gel beads that are embedded within the memory and polyurethane foams. According to Serta, the gel beads improve the coolness of the mattress, particularly when compared to standard foams in the market. Many of Serta’s competitors, as well as reviews from consumers, state that this isn’t true since there have been a number of instances when they would still sleep hot despite such claims. There are also complaints about the iComfort sagging in just after three years of ownership and this can be a problem for people who want a long-lasting mattress.

If you’re interested in the iComfort line, here are some of the models you can choose from:

Serta iComfort (Main Line): This collection has mattresses with three to four pound gel memory foam. There are also some models without the gel, but are still said to remain cool at warm nights. Models include Genius Everfeel, Prodigy Everfeel, and Insight Everfeel among others.

Serta iComfort Directions: This iComfort line features mattress covers with tencel fabric, along with gel-infused memory foam, and graphene. The density of the foams is four pounds and there is an added support layer with gel beads. Directions is almost the same as the main iComfort line, but have been enhanced to provide better cooling and support. Models include Acumen, Reinvention, and Inception.

Serta iComfort EFX: This line is created by Serta, but the company doesn’t sell them directly. It features the same density as the other lines with memory foams that come with gel beads. Some aren’t gel infused, so look closely at the specs of the mattresses before you buy, particularly if you want the gel mattresses. Models include Intellectual EFX, Brilliant EFX, and Aura EFX.

Warranty and Returns

The good news about buying a Serta iComfort mattress is that you can easily return it within 120 days of trying it out. Additionally, the warranty is longer than the industry standard with a total of 25 years – 15 years of which offer full coverage.

With the promise that the memory foam mattresses come with good cooling properties, this collection may be right for you, especially if you’re not worried about the money you spend.

3. Sealy Posturepedic

Sealy Posturepedic is a good choice for people who have back problems.

The mattress line is available in many stores, but can cause a lot of confusion to buyers because they can have varying names from one store to another.

Who will be interested in the Posturepedic line from Sealy?
Posturepedic is for you if you want several mattress options.

You’re more comfortable with buying at stores rather than online.

You are a big fan of innerspring mattresses or you like the combination of innerspring or memory foam.

Why you may want to avoid Sealy Posturepedic
If you don’t want to go from one store to another and try the mattresses out, you’ll probably want to look for other mattresses or brands.

You want a mattress that can last for years.

You prefer a latex mattress or something that uses all-foam.

Sealy is among the oldest mattress companies with its inception back in 1881, manufacturing not only mattresses, but box springs, adjustable frames, pillows, and toppers0 as well. Sealy has focused on latex mattresses, but because of the popularity of memory foam, they started producing such type of mattress, too.

Currently, the most popular line from Sealy is the Posturepedic line, which is especially designed to provide support for those who wake up often because of a back pain. Posturepedic models have added support, particularly to the main part of the body. They also have a larger space than many mattresses and the edges are firmer as well. The top models within this line are Gel, Hybrid, and the Classic series. Posturepedic is created with the help of some orthopedic surgeons in order to come up with mattresses with the right back support. According to Sealy, the mattresses in this line have proper support, which allows better circulation of blood that can lead to a more restful sleep. Here’s an overview of the Posturepedic series:

Classic: This series uses spring coils and extra lumbar support.

Gel: As the name implies, the mattresses in this series have a layer of gel in the memory foam. They are designed to keep the sleeper cool throughout the night.

Hybrid: The mattresses combine features of the series and with pocketed springs. The difference is that Hybrid has more gel in the foams and is a little bit pricier.

The mattresses vary in price depending on the series, along with the features they possess, including more pocketed coils. The higher priced ones are designed to provide even better support and motion transfer reduction.

Some Drawbacks

Before you buy, it is important to understand that some mattresses are not right for you. Sealy Posturepedic may be one of them, especially if you’re looking to buy a pillow top model and you have back pain. There have been a number of complaints about the too soft feel of these models as well the sagging issues, which can cause the sleepers to suffer from backaches. This is quite disappointing due to the fact that Posturepedic was created to prevent back problems.

The problem with sagging claims is that your mattress should reach 1.5 inches in order for the warranty to commence. Unfortunately, not all the mattress owners have reached this sagging depth, so this means they have to wait until they arrive at the mentioned deepness. The waiting period can lead to even more pain and as time passes, support is reduced.

Nevertheless, if you’re set to buy an innerspring or hybrid mattress, you should definitely check Sealy Posturepedic.

4. Simmons BeautyRest

Simmons, especially their BeautyRest line, is one of the most recognizable names in the mattress market.

The mattress line has six collections, including those that feature memory foam and hybrid types.

Don’t be confused with the Simmons BeautyRest and Comforpedic, since the latter has been discontinued.

Why would you think Simmons BeautyRest is a good choice?
You will like the BeautyRest line if you’re looking for a mattress that is good for couples, especially those whose partner moves around a lot when sleeping.

Many sleepers commented how the mattress line is able to help them reduce pain, particularly in the first three years of ownership.

The warranty coverage is quite attractive.

What are the reasons why you may want to avoid this Simmons mattress line?
A number of customers have complained about sagging and impressions problems.

Comfort and pain reduction decrease in efficiency after the first three years.

There are some models in the mattress line that have problems, such as heat retention and off-gassing.

The Simmons BeautyRest is a popular line of mattress from Simmons and has accumulated quite a number of good reviews from many users. Just like the Sealy Posturepedic line, there seems to be a problem with the models under this line, mainly because of the variations in the product names. For example, one store may offer a particular BeautyRest model and then when you go to another store, the name (but not the features) is different. This can definitely create confusion among many consumers, especially when you are searching for reviews on the product.

To make it easier for you, here is an overview of the mattress models under the BeautyRest line:

Recharge: This mattress model is designed for those who are looking for an affordable mattress. Naturally, you cannot compare the Recharge with the other models since this lacks many features. You can, however, expect that there are about 800 pocket coils in this mattress model, which are to provide support for the mattress as a whole. The Recharge has four comfort levels: Plush, Firm, Pillow Top, and Luxury Firm.

Recharge World Class: If you have a slightly higher budget, you can step up to the World Class series, which is similar to Recharge, but with added features. These features include more pocket coils, which are at least 850 to provide better support and motion isolation. The memory foam used feels much cooler than the standard Recharge because of the micro-gel used.

Hybrid: Just like most hybrid mattresses, this model comes with a thick layer of memory foam on top of the pocket coils. Coil count can go up to 2000 coils, while the memory foam uses “gel touch” technology. The Hybrid mattress is more expensive than the Recharge World Class.

Black: Currently, the Black models are the most talked about in the BeautyRest line. Black targets the luxury market, so if you’re price-sensitive, you will probably want to avoid this mattress line. The reason why this is a premium mattress is because of the use of high quality coils featuring a triple braided pocketed coil system known as Veriform. Many owners say that the mattress is effective in eliminating motion transfer and it is durable as well. The foam used is also better than the other models.

Recharge Memory Foam Plus: If you’re looking for a simple memory foam mattress, this one may suit you. It focuses on the use of traditional memory foam, but promises that it has eliminated problems that come with the mattress type, including sleeping hot. Just like the Black models though, you will have to expect to shell out thousands of dollars if you want to buy Recharge Memory Foam Plus.

Also under the BeautyRest line is the Comforpedic or Comforpedic IQ models. They are already discontinued, but there are still a number of retailers around that offer the mattresses. Comforpedic has firm, plush, and medium feel mattresses though there are some issues with the price. You can find more affordable options with similar (or even better features) that are priced just right.

5. Stearns and Foster

Stearns and Foster mattresses are among the most popular luxury mattresses in the market.

The mattresses from the company used to have 25 year warranty, but they have decreased it to just 15 years.

The mattresses can last from five to six years, which is quite longer than other brands, but still shorter than others.

Who would like Stearns and Foster mattresses?
Stearns and Foster mattresses are for those who are looking for luxury mattresses.

The company has been around since 1846, so they are established in the business with a number of satisfied customers.

The mattresses have adequate motion isolation, so it’s recommended for couples.

Who may want to avoid their mattresses?
If you’re looking for a mattress that will fit your budget, Stearns and Foster isn’t one of your choices.

There have been many complaints about the mattress sagging and losing support in just a few years of ownership, Avoid if you want unquestionable durability.

The mattress is quite heavy, which will be hard for you to move to another room.

Stearns and Foster is a mattress brand created by Sealy. The company has been around since the 1800s and has been one of the sources of luxury mattresses. One huge reason why their mattresses are popular is because they look good. Unlike other brands, they don’t have overly bland themes on their mattress, so you don’t really need to spice it up with bedding. Stearns and Foster offers some smart-looking mattresses that are suitable for those who are searching for a modern twist in their bedroom furnishings.

Another good thing about Stearns and Foster mattresses is that there are a lot of choices available. This helps you find the best one that fits your needs. The mattress models do vary in price as well as in comfort level and construction. The most affordable is $1,200, but the most expensive is over $4,000. You can find mattresses that are plush, firm, cushion firm, and very firm. Additionally, they have innerspring mattresses, along with memory foam and innerspring combinations or hybrid mattresses.

Stearns and Foster mattresses are also handmade, which is one of the reasons why they are pricey. The materials, which vary from one model to another, may include silk, Mongolian horsehair, and wool. The company also guarantees the buyers that they are paying for non-toxic mattresses, which means that they do not use harmful chemicals during the manufacturing process. With proper care, the mattresses can last for up to six years. However, the lifespan of the mattress will also depend on the model itself since there are some that are more durable than others.

Some Drawbacks to Know About

There are a few reasons why some consumers avoid Stearns and Foster mattresses. Although the company states that they use natural materials, they don’t really contribute to the support and comfort of the models. For instance, using Mongolian horsehair and silk may sound nice, but you can tell that they don’t offer any benefit for the mattress. Silk is simply added to the fabric of the products and this can actually weaken it and the same thing goes to Mongolian horsehair. While the efforts of the company to come up with something appealing and luxurious-sounding, those lavish materials aren’t really necessary.

Customer satisfaction is also a big problem since there are quite a number of unhappy customers who gave a low rating for the innerspring mattresses from the company. The biggest complaint involves the mattresses wearing down quicker than they expected. Quite obviously, sleepers who experience this problem are quite disappointed when it comes to the durability of the expensive mattresses from Stearns and Foster. This leads to another common issue, which is the price. The cost of the mattresses would have been bearable for many customers if the products don’t have a lot of drawbacks.

Nevertheless, Stearns and Foster and the other four mentioned companies above namely Amerisleep, Sealy, Serta, and Simmons are all well-trusted. These mattress brands have been established with great features that will help you sleep comfortably and undisturbed throughout the night. While the brand does help consumers distinguish one mattress from another, it isn’t the sole factor that influences one’s final decision. There are plenty of other things to consider, including the budget, the features, and the overall sleep experience. In the end, the choice will be yours and you will learn that what really matters is not the brand, but the comfort you enjoy when you lie down on the mattress.